Katie Brooks,
Daniel Brooks,
Zeina Dajani,
Susan M Swetter,
Erin Powers,
Sherry Pagoto,
Alan C Geller
Department of Dermatology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts 02118, USA.
BACKGROUND: Neither the prevalence of sunless tanner use nor its impact on sunburning and tanning bed use has been evaluated in the United States. OBJECTIVE: We surveyed young adults in greater Boston to measure use of artificial tanning products, as well as recent history of sunburns and tanning bed use. METHODS: In July 2004, 448 individuals 18 to 30 years of age completed a brief questionnaire at universities, shopping venues, and parks. RESULTS: Twenty-two percent of respondents used sunless tanning lotions in the preceding 12 months, and another 22% had not used them but would consider doing so in the coming year. Sunless tanning users were more likely to be female, younger, and more likely to report being severe burners. Both users and potential users were more likely to have sunburned during the summer and to have used tanning beds than those who neither used nor intended to use sunless tanning lotions, even after controlling for skin type. LIMITATIONS: The study was based on a non-randomly selected sample in one city and was cross-sectional in nature. CONCLUSION: Our study raises the possibility that sunless tanning products do not decrease rates of sunburning or use of tanning beds. While safe alternatives to ultraviolet exposure are desirable, the potential risks of widely endorsing artificial tanning products must be considered.
Other papers by authors:
In the past 5 years, there have been notable strides toward the earlier recognition and discovery of melanoma, including new technologies to complement and augment the clinical examination and new insights to help clinicians recognize early melanoma. However, incidence and mortality rates throughout most of the developed world have risen over the past 25 years, while education and screening, potentially the best means for reducing the disease, continue to be severely underutilized. Much progress needs to be made to reach middle-aged and older men and persons of lower socioeconomic status who suffer a disproportionate burden of death from melanoma. Worldwide melanoma control must also be a priority, and comprehensive educational and screening programs should be directed to Northern Ireland and a number of Eastern European nations, whose 5-year survival rates range between 53% and 60%, mirroring those of the United States and Australia more than 40 years ago. LEARNING OBJECTIVE: After completing this learning activity, participants should be aware of the most recent melanoma epidemiologic data, both in the United States and internationally; worldwide early detection and screening programs; clinical strategies to recognize and improve the detection of early melanoma; the latest technologies for early detection of melanoma; and public and professional education programs designed to enhance early detection.
BACKGROUND:From 1973 through 2002, melanoma mortality rates have risen steeply in middle-aged and older men. Men's higher mortality rate from melanoma is hardly an isolated example of the ways in which men's health lags behind women's health. Given the significantly higher melanoma mortality rates of men compared with women, there is now a need for a melanoma education program targeted to middle-aged and older men and their closest contacts, including spouses, significant others, and health care professionals.OBJECTIVES:In this article, we discuss the theoretical and practical foundations for such a program. Then, taking into account factors such as socioeconomic status, health literacy, and residence, we present suggestions for creating such a campaign.CONCLUSIONS:Planners for a new educational campaign must understand the target audience's motivations for and perceived barriers to behavioral change. Future studies should examine what motivates certain men to conduct skin self-examinations, ask their physicians about melanoma, and attend melanoma screenings, whereas other men with similar risk factors are less prevention conscious. Issues of health literacy and understandability of our messages must be further explored.
Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA 02118, USA.
PURPOSE: We assessed the placement of magazine advertising for sun care products to lay the groundwork for broader promotion to more diverse and high-risk demographic groups. METHODS: We reviewed 579 issues of 24 magazines published between the months of May and September from 1997 to 2002. We conducted a cover-to-cover review of top-selling magazines for men, women, teens, parents, travelers, and outdoor recreation users. We determined if there were any advertisements for the following sun care products: sun tanning lotions containing sun protection factor (SPF), sunless tanners without SPF, sunscreen with SPF, moisturizers with SPF, or cosmetics with SPF (which include sunless tanners containing SPF. RESULTS: Sun care products, including sunscreens, were advertised primarily in women's magazines (77%). Nearly two thirds of all sun care products advertised were either for cosmetics (38%) or moisturizers (26%) containing SPF, followed by ads for sunscreen sold as a stand-alone product (19%). None of the ads contained all of the recommendations for safe use of sunscreen: a minimum SPF of 15, both UVA and UVB protection, reapplication instructions, and an adequate application coverage of 2 milligrams per square centimeter. DISCUSSION: Magazine advertising to men, travelers, outdoor recreation users, and parents/families (totaling a circulation of 41 million readers) during this six-year period were far fewer than those for women, despite high rates of excessive sun exposure in these groups.
1Department of Dermatology, Pigmented Lesion and Melanoma Program, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California; 2Division of Public Health Practice, Harvard School of Public Health; 3Department of Epidemiology, Boston University School of Public Health; Departments of 4Dermatology, 5Otolaryngology, and 6Surgery, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan; 7Department of Medicine and 8Institute for Health Policy, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts; and 9Dermatology Service, Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System, Palo Alto, California.
Although skin self-examination (SSE) may increase rates of early melanoma detection, the efficacy of different SSE practices has not been thoroughly studied. We examined associations between SSE practices and tumor thickness in patients with recently diagnosed melanoma. METHODS: 321 melanoma patients at three hospitals completed questionnaires on demographics and SSE practices. Patient-reported SSE was measured by routine examination of 13 specific body areas, frequency of mole examination, and use of a melanoma picture aid to assist with SSE. Histologic diagnoses and Breslow depth were confirmed by dermatopathologists. Regression analyses were used to calculate ratios of geometric mean tumor thickness and odds ratios for having thicker versus thinner tumors for different SSE behaviors. RESULTS: Rates of SSE varied considerably by SSE item. Patients routinely examining at least some of their skin had thinner melanomas [adjusted geometric mean tumor ratio, .73; 95% confidence interval (95% CI), .50- .94]. Frequency of mole examination did not predict tumor thickness. Using a melanoma picture as a SSE aid was strongly associated with reduced tumor thickness (adjusted ratio, .75; 95% CI, .66- .85 for ever versus never use). A composite measure of thoroughness of SSE was the best predictor of thickness (adjusted ratio, .58; 95% CI, .36- .75) for high versus low thoroughness. CONCLUSIONS: SSE was associated with decreased tumor thickness by most measures. However, the diverse rates of SSE practices and the distinct associations between these practices and melanoma thickness suggest a complexity in SSE that should be addressed in future studies. SSE should be evaluated by more than one measure.(Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2009;18(11):3018-23).
Susan M Swetter,
Christle J Layton,
Timothy M Johnson,
Katie R Brooks,
Donald R Miller,
Alan C Geller
Alan C Geller,
Timothy M Johnson,
Donald R Miller,
Katie R Brooks,
Christle J Layton,
Susan M Swetter
Department of Dermatology, Boston University School of Medicine, 720 Harrison Ave, DOB 801A, Boston, MA 02118, USA. ageller@bu.edu
OBJECTIVE: To determine factors associated with physician discovery of early melanoma in middle-aged and older men. DESIGN: Survey. SETTING: Three institutional melanoma clinics. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 227 male participants (aged > or =40 years) with invasive melanoma who completed surveys within 3 months of diagnosis. Intervention Survey. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Factors associated with physician-detected thin melanoma. RESULTS: Patients with physician-detected melanoma were older, 57% were 65 years or older compared with 34% for other-detected (odds ratio [OR], 2.57; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.19-5.55) and 42% for patient-detected melanoma (P =.07). Physician-detected melanoma in the oldest patients (aged > or =65 years) had tumor thickness equal to that of self-detected melanoma or melanoma detected by other means in younger patients. Back lesions composed 46% of all physician-detected melanoma, 57% of those detected by other means, and 16% of self-detected lesions (physician- vs self-detected: OR, 4.25; 95% CI, 1.96-9.23). Ninety-two percent of all physician-detected back-of-the-body melanomas were smaller than 2 mm compared with 63% of self-detected lesions (P =.004) and 76% of lesions detected by other means (P =.07). CONCLUSIONS: Skin screenings of at-risk middle-aged and older American men can be integrated into the routine physical examination, with particular emphasis on hard-to-see areas, such as the back of the body."Watch your back" professional education campaigns should be promoted by skin cancer advocacy organizations.
Susan M Swetter,
Timothy M Johnson,
Donald R Miller,
Christle J Layton,
Katie R Brooks,
Alan C Geller
Department of Dermatology, Stanford University Medical Center, 900 Blake Wilbur Dr, Room W0069, Stanford, CA 94305, USA. sswetter@stanford.edu
OBJECTIVES: To identify factors related to the detection of melanoma and to determine those that differ between thinner vs thicker tumors in middle-aged and older men. DESIGN: Survey. SETTING: Three institutional melanoma clinics. PARTICIPANTS: Men 40 years or older who had newly diagnosed invasive melanoma. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Differences in melanoma awareness, skin examination practices, discovery patterns, and social/medical care factors relative to tumor thickness. RESULTS: Two hundred twenty-seven men completed surveys within 3 months of melanoma diagnosis; 57 (25.1%) had thicker tumors (>2.00 mm). Thicker tumors were associated with nodular histologic features (43.9%), a lack of atypical nevi, having less than a high school education, and patient vs physician (dermatologist or nondermatologist) detection. Knowledge of melanoma (P =.007), attention to skin cancer detection information (P =.02), an interest in health topics (P =.003), and knowing the importance of physician skin examination (P =.05) were more common in those with thin tumors. Tumor thickness did not correlate with age, anatomic location, marital/cohabitation status, prior skin cancer, or sun sensitivity. Overall patient awareness of melanoma warning signs, skin self-examination practices, and Internet use were poor (<20%,<50%, and <14%, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Physician discovery, the patient's higher level of education and detection-promoting awareness and attitudes, and the presence of clinically atypical nevi were related to thinner melanomas. Innovative outreach strategies and novel educational campaigns incorporating these factors, coupled with sharper messages regarding the importance of physician screening, are needed to improve early detection in middle-aged and older men.
Alan C Geller,
Mark Elwood,
Susan M Swetter,
Daniel R Brooks,
Joanne Aitken,
Philippa H Youl,
Marie-France Demierre,
Peter D Baade
Division of Public Health Practice, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts.
BACKGROUND:: Worldwide, the incidence of thick melanoma has not declined, and the nodular melanoma (NM) subtype accounts for nearly 40% of newly diagnosed thick melanoma. To assess differences between patients with thin (</=2.00 mm) and thick (>/=2.01 mm) nodular melanoma, the authors evaluated factors such as demographics, melanoma detection patterns, tumor visibility, and physician screening for NM alone and compared clinical presentation and anatomic location of NM with superficial spreading melanoma (SSM). METHODS:: The authors used data from a large population-based study of Queensland (Australia) residents diagnosed with melanoma. Queensland residents aged 20 to 75 years with histologically confirmed first primary invasive cutaneous melanoma were eligible for the study, and all questionnaires were conducted by telephone (response rate, 77.9%). RESULTS:: During this 4-year period, 369 patients with nodular melanoma were interviewed, of whom 56.7% were diagnosed with tumors </=2.00 mm. Men, older individuals, and those who had not been screened by a physician in the past 3 years were more likely to have nodular tumors of greater thickness. Thickest nodular melanoma (4 mm+) was also most common in persons who had not been screened by a physician within the past 3 years (odds ratio, 3.75; 95% confidence interval, 1.47-9.59). Forty-six percent of patients with thin nodular melanoma (</=2.00 mm) reported a change in color, compared with 64% of patients with thin SSM and 26% of patients with thick nodular melanoma (>2.00 mm). CONCLUSIONS:: Awareness of factors related to earlier detection of potentially fatal nodular melanomas, including the benefits of a physician examination, should be useful in enhancing public and professional education strategies. Particular awareness of clinical warning signs associated with thin nodular melanoma should allow for more prompt diagnosis and treatment of this subtype. Cancer 2009.(c) 2009 American Cancer Society.
Latest similar papers:
Jo M Martin,
Jessica M Ghaferi,
Deborah L Cummins,
Adam J Mamelak,
Chrys D Schmults,
Mona Parikh,
Lark-Aeryn Speyer,
Alice Chuang,
Hazel V Richardson,
David Stein,
Nanette J Liégeois
Johns Hopkins University, School of Medicine.
Historical reviews suggest that tanning first became fashionable in the 1920s or 1930s. To quantitatively and qualitatively examine changes in tanning attitudes portrayed in the popular women's press during the early 20th century, we reviewed summer issues of Vogue and Harper's Bazaar for the years 1920, 1927, 1928, and 1929. We examined these issues for articles and advertisements promoting skin tanning or skin bleaching and protection. We found that articles and advertisements promoting the fashionable aspects of tanned skin were more numerous in 1928 and 1929 than in 1927 and 1920, whereas those promoting pale skin (by bleaching or protection) were less numerous. These findings demonstrate a clear shift in attitudes toward tanned skin during this period.
Latrice C Pichon,
Joni A Mayer,
Katherine D Hoerster,
Susan I Woodruff,
Donald J Slymen,
George E Belch,
Elizabeth J Clapp,
Ami L Hurd,
Jean L Forster,
Martin A Weinstock
Graduate School of Public Health, 9245 Sky Park Ct, Ste 220, San Diego, CA 92123, USA.
OBJECTIVE: To assess indoor tanning facility practices in a sample of facilities in 116 cities representing all 50 states. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: United States. PARTICIPANTS: Employees of 3647 indoor tanning facilities were contacted by telephone. Data collectors (ie, confederates) posed as prospective, fair-skinned, 15-year-old female customers who had never tanned before. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Confederates asked respondents about their facility's practices related to parental consent, parental accompaniment, and allowable tanning session frequency. RESULTS: Approximately 87% of the facilities required parental consent, 14% required parental accompaniment, 5% said they would not allow the confederate to tan owing to her age, and 71% would allow tanning every day the first week of indoor tanning. In Wisconsin, which bans indoor tanning among those younger than 16 years, 70% of facilities would not allow the confederate to tan. Multivariate analyses indicated that facilities in states with a youth access law were significantly more likely to require parental consent (P <.001) and parental accompaniment (P <.001) than those in states without a youth access law. Law was not significantly related to allowable tanning frequency (P =.81). Conclusion We recommend that additional states pass youth access legislation, preferably in the form of bans.
Department of Dermatology, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Center, Nijmegen, The Netherlands. j.bovenschen@derma.umcn.nl
Miami, FL.
The modern formulation of dihydroxyacetone (DHA), the only sunless tanning solution approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), is combined with bronzers and moisturizers to deliver a cosmetically acceptable skin color and a natural-looking tan without ultraviolet (UV) exposure. Spray-on tanning products, which deliver this formulation evenly to achieve a full body tan, may be applied in a tanning booth, airbrushed on by a technician, or sprayed on at home, and they appear to offer a generally safe alternative for patients who seek a suntanned appearance.
Department of Dermatology and Allergology, Ruhr-University Bochum, Bochum, Germany.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: We examined the prevalence of indoor tanning in North Rhine-Westphalia and identified correlates of sunbed use. METHODS: During regular skin cancer screening campaigns 1242 subjects completed and returned a structured questionnaire on constitutional parameters and indoor tanning habits. RESULTS: The regular sunbed user rate (more than 10 exposures/year) was 15.4%(191/1242). Most sunbed users were under 29 years of age. The number of female sunbed users was greater than the number of male users. Respondents with secondary modern school qualification used sunbeds more infrequently than respondents with junior high school and high school qualifications. Respondents with skin type III and IV used sunbeds more frequently. Tanning and preparation for sunny holidays were the main reasons for sunbed use. The most frequently reported positive effects experienced by means of sunbed use were improved appearance and relaxation. Most respondents indicated that they hardly or never had sunburns following indoor tanning. Almost half of respondents consider radiation generated by sunbeds somewhat dangerous. CONCLUSIONS: Use of indoor tanning in North Rhine-Westphalia has increased and is significantly associated with female gender, younger age, high-level education, and skin type III and IV. The motivation for sunbed use and benefits experienced are mainly based on the perception of improved appearance due to tan and increased sense of well-being.
Claudia Salomone,
Daniela Majerson,
Montserrat Molgó,
Mariá Luisa Sáenz de Santa María,
William Romero
Department of Dermatology, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile. csalomon@uc.cl
INTRODUCTION: In recent years, the use of artificial tanning devices has become very popular in Chile. In April, 2007, a new law was established to regulate the non-medical use of tanning beds and tanning booths. The aim of this study was to evaluate the level and quality of information provided by tanning salon staff to clients before deciding on using the services. This information was collected before and 6 months after the law was enacted by researchers visiting tanning salons posing as potential clients. METHODS: Using a previously designed questionnaire, 24 tanning salons in Santiago, Chile, were evaluated by researchers acting as potential customers without experience with artificial tanning devices. Employees were questioned using a hidden questionnaire before and 6 months after enactment of the law. RESULTS: Before the law, 25% of the establishments gave spontaneous information about the risks of using tanning beds, which increased to 45.8% after enactment of the law. Clients never received written information, either before or after enactment of the law. On both evaluations, more than 1/3 of the employees affirmed that there were no risks in using tanning beds. Before enactment of the law, only 12.5% of the tanning salons required the use of goggles, while after the law, this increased to 25%(P=NS). Only two establishments required that clients sign an informed consent form after enactment of the law. DISCUSSION: The level of knowledge among employees in tanning salons was very low and the quality of the information they provided to the clients was very poor. It was important to legislate on ultraviolet tanning services, but at present, the impact of the law has been very limited.
Deann Lazovich,
Jo Ellen Stryker,
Joni A Mayer,
Joel Hillhouse,
Leslie K Dennis,
Latrice Pichon,
Sherry Pagoto,
Carolyn Heckman,
Ardis Olson,
Vilma Cokkinides,
Kevin Thompson
Division of Epidemiology and Community Health, University of Minnesota, 1300 S 2nd St, Ste 300, Minneapolis, MN 55454. lazovich@epi.umn.edu.
OBJECTIVE: To develop items to measure indoor tanning and sunless tanning that can be used to monitor trends in population surveys or to assess changes in behavior in intervention studies. DESIGN: A group of experts on indoor tanning convened in December 2005, as part of a national workshop to review the state of the evidence, define measurement issues, and develop items for ever tanned indoors, lifetime frequency, and past-year frequency for both indoor tanning and sunless tanning. Each item was subsequently assessed via in-person interviews for clarity, specificity, recall, and appropriateness of wording. SETTING: Universities in Tennessee and Virginia, a medical center in Massachusetts, and a high school in New Hampshire. PARTICIPANTS: The study population comprised 24 adults and 7 adolescents. RESULTS: Participants understood indoor tanning to represent tanning from beds, booths, and lamps that emit artificial UV radiation, rather than sunless tanning, even though both can be obtained from a booth. Two items were required to distinguish manually applied from booth-applied sunless tanning products. Frequency of use was easier for participants to recall in the past year than for a lifetime. CONCLUSIONS: While indoor tanning items may be recommended with confidence for clarity, sunless tanning items require additional testing. Memory aids may be necessary to facilitate recall of lifetime use of nonsolar tanning. In addition, studies that assess reliability and validity of these measures are needed. Since study participants were primarily young and female, testing in other populations should also be considered.
